admittedly, I can appreciate that this is a beautiful photograph, but can this even matter, when the girl is so, so young? Do ethics matter in art? Even if they don't, this isn't simply a matter of art it's a matter of the media, where surely there HAS to be ethics.
I think the only times I ever wore heels at such a young age was secretly dressing up in my mums shoes. Don't get me wrong, all young girls want to play dress up, and maybe, for this girl, thats all this was... except for the rest of the world, for the adult world, it's so much more than that. Why would a glamourous 20 year old french vogue reader want to look at pictures of a young girl pretending to be a woman? Plus, just to add fuel to the fire, how can the world argue about protecting children from adult things and disgusting predators, when at the same time the media, which is arguable one of the most dominating forces in the 21st century universe, throws young girls into the spotlight in such an obvious way?
I had similar thoughts when Willow Smith, at just NINE released 'whip my hair', surely she is too young to cope with the vicious demands of being a successful singer in the spotlight... but this photo in French Vogue seems to go so much further...
is this a good thing or a bad thing? Young girls look up to models, actresses, and singers... is it better if those people are there own age? Or does it create false expectations of the need to look a certain way, of growing up too fast? Do I sound old, like I don't understand? I don't think so. I think this is sick. And I think that the media should take responsibility. When young girls model they should model as young girls, not dressed up as sickly sweet adults.